Wednesday, November 25, 2015

Long lens – types and choices


Nikkor  AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-300mm f/4.5-5.6G
at 165 mm, ISO 100, f/10, 1/100 s
My last blog post was about testing a variety of zoom lenses to hopefully end up buying one.

This post is my attempt to explain my decision-making to hopefully help others with their own choices.

As I understand it, there are two types of long lenses, zoom and prime lenses. Zoom lenses will cover a range of focal lengths, whereas prime lenses will have one focal length.

Zoom lenses may vary their widest aperture according to the focal length, or have a constant aperture. The latter allows you to zoom in and out as much as you like without changing exposure - one less thing to worry about. Another factor to consider is the widest possible aperture. The wider the aperture, more light is allowed to come in, making it possible to take good pictures in situation where light is dim and/or the subject is moving. Lens that open up to a wide aperture are sometimes refereed to as “fast”.

For example, my late Nikon 55-200mm f/4-5.6G had an aperture that varies between 4 (at 55 mm) to 5.6 (at 200 mm), and that is pretty standard for this kind of consumer lens that cost below 500 U$. It is good for taking pictures of still subjects when there is a lot of light, or with a tripod when there is a little less light, but it is considered “slow”. The Nikon 70-200 mm 2.8G , on the other hand, not only has constant aperture, but it is also “faster”. This type of lens is better for sports photography, low light situations and moving objects such as flying birds etc. It also costs four times as much.

Months ago, I could not understand why some flickr members could get perfectly in-focus shots of flying birds whereas I could not, at the same focal length. Not only they have faster lenses, but also, very likely, better constructed lenses.

Note that a f/3.5-5.6 can gather more light at the wide end (where you can use f/3.5) then a constant aperture f/4 lens - but if you need to zoom in suddenly you have to change the ISO or shutter speed to compensate for your changing aperture.

I do not know of any disadvantage of having a fast zoom with constant aperture, and I would have gotten one if I could afford one. Among the choices I had, however, price, users' reviews, and whether there is a promotion on the lens or not were the most decisive factors.

And this is the lens I chose: Nikon AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-300mm f/4.5-5.6G . Why? It had good reviews and I found one refurbished for a little less than the regular price. On the downside, it came with 3 month warranty, in stead of the regular 4 years Nikon offers. I may regret this move later, but with a child in college and some recent unexpected expenses, I was not ready to pay much for a lens.

Why did I not chose a Tamrom? Well, first I could not get a good deal on any of the lenses I had tested. Second, the one I was aiming for more strongly, the 70-300 mm, was apparently underexposing the pictures, leading the camera's exposure algorithm to up the ISO more than it would be expected under the light situations. When I looked at the exposure information on my photos from the zoo, I first though that I had done something wrong, but when I went look at consumers' evaluations, I found out that other photographers also came across the same problem.

Nikkor  AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-300mm f/4.5-5.6G
at 98 mm, ISO 800, f/4.5 1/500 s



Thursday, November 19, 2015

Joys and sorrows of choosing a long lens

I had been very dissatisfied with my Nikkor 55-200 and at some point I sent it to Amazon trade in. I never felt so good in my life, knowing that I would no longer be disappointed by it.

But then I had to chose another long lens, on a budget, and not knowing much of anything. I do not like choosing among a set of equivalent alternatives; it is stressful, time-consuming, and more often than not, it ends up in dissatisfaction. I am convinced that one of the greatest sorrows of our western society is having too many choices. However, I knew a few things that had the potential to shorten my agony: 1) I wanted a zoom in the range of 55-300 mm; and 2) I could not afford a lens with constant aperture (unfortunately). For those who are not accustomed to different lenses and focal lengths, Nikon has a nice introductory site about it.

Thankfully, a local photography store, Mike's camera of Sacramento, had an event at the zoo in which we could try out different lenses, cameras and tripods for free. I did go and I took a number of pictures. I first had in mind to purchase the Tamron 70-300 mm for the price and also because of some good (though not too excited) reviews on Amazon and u-tube. It was the first lens that I tried in the event.

Since I was handholding the camera, for every lens I tried, I made sure to use the minimum shutter speed for my focal length, with and without Vibration Reduction (see nice chart by Digital Camera World). To do that, I put the camera in shutter priority and left the ISO free to vary.

Obviously the systematic test that I had envisioned did not work out as well as I had predicted, but I got to try out the Tamron 70-300 mm, the Tamron18-200 mm (no Amazon link) and the Tamron16-300 mm (the link if for a Canon mount but I tried, obviously, the one with a Nikon mount). They were all excellent lenses and in the end of the day, I was not sure how to compare among them. Below a few photos I took with each.

The photo of the Orangutan, below, was taken using spot metering because the light was behind it, and that might explain the high ISO the camera chose after I dialed in the shutter speed. Despite that, it is still a good photo, sharp on the face, where I focused.

Nikon D3100
Tamron 70-300 mm f/4-5.6 at 200 mm, ISO 1600, f/5.3, 1/320

The bird below, like all photographs that follow, was photographed with matrix metering and a shutter speed slightly faster than I would need. The result is not as good as the photo above, but the conditions were awful (low light, having to bypass the grid etc).

Nikon D3100
Tamron 70-300 mm f/4-5.6 at 95 mm, ISO 180, f/4.2, 1/125


From the start I had agreed with myself to dislike the Tamrom 18-200 mm, probably because I wanted to go up to 300 mm.  Yet the photo below is one of a number that I took with it. The photo is surprisingly good, considering my lack of experience.

Nikon D3100
Tamron 18-200 mm f/3.5 -6.3 at 95 mm, ISO 200, f/8, 1/250

And finally, a lens that I liked very much, the Tamron 16-300 mm.

Nikon D3100

Tamron 16-300 mm f/3.5 -6.3 at 300 mm, ISO 400, f/6.3, 1/400


I was happy and grateful to be able to try out these lenses until I stumbled upon Mike's camera's crew letting us put our cameras on their prime super zooms... and below a photo with my favorite lens:

Nikon D3100
AF-S VR Nikkor 600 mm f/4G ED
ISO 100, f/5.4, 1/500
spot metering
And yes, I did end up buying a zoom, and next post I will talk about it.

Sunday, November 15, 2015

Ladybugs galore in a deep canyon

Yesterday we went look for ladybugs in the Stevens Trail in Colfax. This is a 8-mi round trip trail off Colfax, CA. It descends into the American River, which lies in a deep canyon. During the descent there are gorgeous views of the river. Given the depth of the canyon, however, only short portions of the river are illuminated by the sun at any time, while the surroundings remain in deep, deep shade. This is by no means a good situation for photography.

Last Saturday, I went with some hikers to look for the ladybugs that gather in this trail every winter. When days start getting shorter and temperatures fall, ladybugs seek shelter under leaves, behind bark, or in other protected locations. Thousands of ladybugs may gather in the same location, taking advantage of the collective warmth of a colony.

Since this was a hiking outing, not a photography one, I only took my 35mm prime and my polarizer. This lens is light, it lets a lot of light in, and therefore it is perfect for situations of low light. Obviously I would have taken a macro lens if I had one.

On our way down, I ventured to take a few photos of the view, pretty much certain that I was not going to get any good results. It was already 9:30 a.m. when we started our descent. Therefore, there was a significant blue cast on everything, plus haze. Below is a photo of the view during the descent. It was taken handheld, with the polarizer on, and it has been significantly cropped to get rid of the highlights on top of the picture. The contrast between light and shade is very evident.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 400, f/8, 1/80

This photo, also handheld and with the polarizer on (though at no point during this trip I was able to be 90 degrees with respect to the sun), shows a bit of the trail, which in portions edges a deep cliff.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 400, f/10, 1/200
When we got to the button, the ladybugs were there! And, they looked very cold. In the two pictures below, I had to use the fill flash since there was not enough light, and I did not have a tripod.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/8, 1/100
fill flash




NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/8, 1/100
fill flash

And finally, a photograph of the American River, from the canyon. A tripod would have helped the depth of field, but since I was handholding the camera, I was not able to close the aperture any further. At this point obviously I was not using the polarizer.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/5, 1/60




Saturday, November 7, 2015

Oil and water photography


This blog post will be very simple. I have learned a trick to take pictures of oil and water that I will explain below. I learned this from an excellent book on photography, Understanding exposure, by Bryan Peterson. Some examples are below:







What you will need:

  • two cups
  • a glass bread pan
  • water
  • cooking oil
  • a colorful piece of cloth
  • a long lens with macro extension tube, or macro lens
  • a tripod
  • patience

Place the grass bread pan atop the the two cups, fill with water up to 2/3, and drop a few drops of cooking oil on the water. Then focus on the colorful bubbles that form and watch on the view finder until a patter forms that you like. Fire away. Make sure to use either a remote shutter release or the timing on your camera so your photos won't get blurred.

You will have to figure out the right exposure, but the picture in the book (page 73) was taken at 200mm, f/11, ISO 200, 1/60s

Photo of the basic setup
  

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Portland and a little street photography

I like some kinds of street photography. Though I cannot put what I like into words, I know what I don't like: badly framed, blurred photos of people passing by with their backs to the camera, or “candid” shots of people doing mundane things or looking undignified in some way. I am also not fond of candid photos of people living on the street. They are not there for our entertainment.

Last weekened was time to visit my child, who attends college in Oregon. We met in Portland and spent the weekened there. Though it was not a photography-oriented weekened, I did take my camera and took a few opportunities to use it in town.

I needed to travel light and I knew that Portland is often overcast, so I took my 35 mm prime and only that lens. Though some might argue that it is not the best phocal length for street photography, I like it just fine, particularly because it is the only prime lens that I own. Since I did not take a tripod, I knew I could operate with a shutter speed of 1/60 just fine, and that I would go home with sharp images.

I really liked the shoe store sign below. This was one of the instances when I missed having a zoom lens, since I wanted to zoom in the shoe store sign and have the rest of the busy stuff out of the frame. Trying to compensate for the wide angle view and great sharpness across the frame, in addition to busy stuff I did not want, I did a little post-processing, as follows. Below is the original photo, processed from raw, orginal size. It is 14,155 pixels.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/7.1, 1/200
First, I cropped the photo to get rid of most of the sky, and the wire, which were not really doing anything. I also sharpened it with Topaz. Second, I used Photoshop Element's filter “old fashion photo” - “newspaper” to render it black and white with high contrast. This took care of some of the distracting elements in the background and made the shoe pop up. This image is 7858 pixels, still large enough to print.


I love neon signs and have started a collection of those. On the way out of a pizza place, I took the chance to grab this photo. I let the camera handle it for me (I put it in automatic). The photo below is enhanced with Topaz HDR II filter:

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 400, f/4, 1/60
The photo below is a parking garage at the PSU campus. I was photographing the wall painting when a person happened to pass by, browsing a phone. I like the contrast between the book covers painted on the wall and the phone, which now symbolizes most of the reading a young person is willing to do. Note that I was using a relatively wide aperture, 3.5, but since I was photographing a painting, it would not have mattered. Note that the subject ended up a little blurred not only because he was walking and my shutter speed was not fast enough to freeze movement, but also because there was probably not enough depth of field to render the person, and the wall, sharp. But I still like it...

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/3.5, 1/80
Besides the city, we also went to the Washington Park, where we visited the Rose Test Garden and the Holocaust memorial. The lens was definitely not appropriate for flowers, but I did take a few pictures I like. The one below I am particularly fond of, it is me smelling a rose. My son had to take it since I had not carried a tripod. The original is a little over saturated and that was particularly visible on the roses. Having to desaturate the photo has given it a somewhat unreal climate, which I like. I also applied some vignette using Elements 9 to get rid of some of the background, which was not blurred because my focal length was short.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 400, f/5, 1/100
And lastly, a sculpture in the Holocaust Memorial, taken with a very wide aperture for shallow depth of field... It was further slightly softened using a Topaz filter.

NIKON D3100
35 mm f/1.8, ISO 100, f/2, 1/160

Wednesday, October 21, 2015

Rush Ranch and Topaz filters

I like to visit mundane places for photography. Think about it. It is great to go to the Mono Lake, the Yosemite National Park, or near San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge to take a shot, but when you are there and you feel pressed to stop and shoot from every postcard view, you know that many people before you have already taken that photo, and that probably there are much better photos of that place out there on the internet.

This weekend I joined a Meetup group to go explore and photograph a virtually unheard of place by most photographers, Rush Ranch. I did not know what to expect. The day started out with clouds, and on my way there a few drops feel from the sky. This is really unusual around here in the middle of October, and I knew it was going to be a lucky photography day.

The ranch is about 2 miles south on CA-12 off I-80, and on the way to Grizzly Island. CA-12 is narrow and wavy on that stretch.

The ranch is small, and the central portion of it has a barn, some animals, a small visitors' center, and an old farm equipment graveyard, besides a blacksmith shop and a native plants' garden. Beyond that, some trails on the grass, towards the rolling hills.

I had only one lens with me, my 35mm prime. I figured that it would be sufficient for most shots and that I could hand hold it in that overcast day without having to use a very fast shutter speed. I started out in the graveyard, where I took some shots of an old Chevrolet. The one below includes the wind mill, and since it was taken with a relatively small aperture (7.1), everything beyond the car is a little out of focus, but still has enough detail. There is a little lens distortion in the image, because I shot pointing the camera up and was I using a wide angle lens. 

The photo below was minimally processed from raw and then I applied Topaz' detail filter HDR I. 

Nikon D3100
35.0 mm f/1.8, ISO 100 f/7.1. 1/320 sec
I was a little taken aback when I arrived home and noticed an unusual amount of fringing in some photos of the Chevrolet. I am not sure what caused it, since I was shooting around f/8 and the 35 mm prime is usually free of fringing. I had not noticed it at first, but using the Topaz filters brought the fringing up very clearly and I started noticing it more. The photo below had virtually none, luckily.

After taking pictures around the graveyard we went on a short trail toward a view and encountered some interesting characters … It has been many years since I last saw an appaloosa horse. The two photos below have also been post-processed with Topaz filters.


Nikon D3100
35.0 mm f/1.8 ISO 100, f/6.3, 1/500 sec

Nikon D3100
35.0 mm f/1.8 ISO 100, f/6.3, 1/500 sec

I am generally satisfied with the results, and since this place is not too far from my house, I will make a point to go there more often.




Saturday, October 17, 2015

Simple things to remember about exposure

Exposure and the camera's meter:

A photograph is correctly exposed when it looks like you intended, not brighter or darker. 



underexposed picture


correctly exposed picture
overexposed picture
The camera's light meter will show 
  • "0" when the exposure is "correct";
  • Positive numbers when it is on the bright side; 
  • Negative numbers when it is on the dark side.


Aperture:

  • Depth of field determines how much of the photo is in focus;
  •  Aperture adjusts how large of an opening the lens makes to let light in;
    •  Small aperture numbers like f/1.8 correspond to a larger opening. This lets more light in and depth of field will be shallow;
    • Big numbers like f/18 correspond to a smaller opening, less light in, and deeper depth of field.
sarge
aperture (shallow depth of field)
f.2.2

small aperture
deeper depth of field
f/8

Shutter Speed:

  • The slower your shutter speed, the more light you get;
  • The faster your shutter speed, the less light you get;
  • In the viewfinder, 100 means a shutter speed of 1/100;
  • Shutter speeds of 1/60 or less  cannot usually be handheld;
  • For telephoto lenses, even faster shutter speeds are needed to handhold the camera, a rule of thumb is for a 100mm lens you need 1/100 or faster, 300mm = 1/300 or faster, 500mm = 1/500 or faster, etc.

ISO:

  • SO determines how fast your image is recorded;
  • ISO 100 will record light the slowest (less light);
  • ISO 800 will record light 8x faster than ISO 100 (more light);
  • Higher ISO's will result in more noise or "graininess" in your image.


  • Each setting effects the others;
  • You can test how aperture and shutter speed relate to one another in this camera simulator for awhile. And note that ISO relates to aperture and shutter speed in the same way.